Bright vaulted living room with neutral furnishings and an oak dining table overlooking a tidy fenced backyard in late fall.

Two Subdivisions on Shallowater's 12th Street Set the Price of a New Home

Both of Shallowater's in-town new-construction neighborhoods sit on 12th Street. Highland Heights is at 12th Street and Avenue P. Highland Trails, which GMC Developments calls an extension of its Highland subdivisions, is at 12th Street and Avenue U. Both are GMC Developments subdivisions, and the developer describes each as within walking distance of the four Shallowater ISD campuses.

Because the two share a developer, a street and a location, the real difference between them is the size of house each one is built around. That size does more to set the starting price of a new Shallowater home than any builder's finish package does. The resale homes on the older blocks nearby show what the premium for buying new comes to this fall.

Each Subdivision Is Built Around a House Size

Highland Heights has 69 lots in Phase One, built out with single-family homes and duplexes, and 73 single-family lots in Phase Two. Phase Two lots are 50, 55 or 62 feet wide and 115 feet deep, and GMC's Highland Heights page lists a 1,450-square-foot minimum. On GMC's plat map, a 62-foot lot comes to about 0.16 acre. The builders named on that plat map include VBA Homes, BBA Homes, Roten Homes and Homes by Lyons. GMC advertises Highland Heights homes "starting in the $300's" on its Highland Heights page.

Highland Trails is a larger product. Lots are a half acre and up, 110 to 150 feet wide and 180 to 200 feet deep, and the developer markets custom homes of at least 2,400 square feet. Like Highland Heights, it has no HOA. GMC advertises homes starting in the $520s and labels the plat map with "38 lots available." Open Highland Trails lots on GMC's plat cards are posted at $99,999 for one and $79,999 for two others, all marked ready to build. Those cards carry no date, and GMC last updated both subdivision pages in late June 2026, so treat every developer figure here as advertised pricing to confirm before you rely on it.

Highland Heights, Phase Two Highland Trails
Location 12th St. & Ave. P 12th St. & Ave. U
Lot size 50, 55 or 62 ft wide, 115 ft deep 110 to 150 ft wide, 180 to 200 ft deep
Minimum home size 1,450 sq ft 2,400 sq ft
Advertised homes From the $300s From the $520s
Utilities Full city utilities City water, builder-installed septic
HOA None None

What One Finished House Says About the Math

As of mid-November, one active listing shows what Highland Heights pricing looks like in practice. Frazier Custom Homes built 1429 15th Street in 2026. It has 1,604 square feet, 3 bedrooms and 2 baths on a 0.13-acre lot, with a two-car garage, a living-room fireplace, an island kitchen and luxury vinyl flooring. It was listed October 5, 2026 at $295,000, which works out to about $184 a square foot. That puts a finished new home just under the "$300's" the developer advertises.

Applied to Highland Trails, a 2,400-square-foot house at $184 a square foot comes to about $441,600. Add a lot at the $79,999 to $99,999 GMC has posted, and you land between roughly $521,600 and $541,600. That lines up with GMC's "homes starting in the $520s." This is our arithmetic, not a builder quote, and Highland Trails homes are custom builds whose finishes can push the per-foot cost well above a spec home's. Still, the advertised floor matches what the minimum house plus a lot would cost. In both subdivisions, the starting price comes mostly from the house size the developer builds around.

For context across the metro, the Lubbock Association of Realtors reported a $256,000 median sale price for the Lubbock MSA in September 2026, along with 46 average days on market and 4.0 months of inventory. In September 2026 terms, the entry point for new construction in Shallowater sat about $39,000 above that metro median.

Resale on the Older Grid Prices the Premium

Shallowater's older streets show what the new-construction premium buys. As of mid-November, four resale homes on the town's established blocks were asking well below the new build on a per-foot basis:

Address Year built Sq ft Asking price Per sq ft Listed
1411 6th Street 1984 1,580 $250,000 $158.23 Oct. 7, 2026
1304 8th Street 1965 2,241 $285,000 $127.18 Oct. 16, 2026
1003 8th Street 1945 1,614 $165,000 $102.23 Sept. 30, 2026
1319 6th Street 1961 2,006 $199,900 $99.65 Aug. 1, 2026

The closest comparison is 1411 6th Street. It is 24 square feet smaller than the Frazier house and asks $45,000 less, which is the gap between a 1984 home and a 2026 one at nearly the same size. 1304 8th Street goes the other direction. It has 637 more square feet than the new build for $10,000 less, on a house built in 1965. The 6th Street listing at 1319 dropped its price 5% to $199,900 on August 28, 2026.

Spread across those four resales, the new-construction premium in Shallowater runs from about $26 to $84 a square foot this fall. A buyer paying it is paying for a new roof, new systems and current layouts. In Highland Trails, the premium also buys room. GMC says those lots are large enough for an RV shop, a hobby building or a pool.

Utilities and the City's Water Work

Highland Heights lots have full city utilities. Highland Trails lots have City of Shallowater water, and the builder installs a septic system on each one. GMC markets that septic setup as a way to save on monthly city fees. The current charges are on the City of Shallowater's water and sewer page. Its FY 2025-26 sheet lists a $45.48 "Lubbock Water" fee per residential meter, since the city buys its water from Lubbock, plus a residential sewer base rate of $19.08. The council had water rates on its agendas for September 15 and October 19, 2026, so call Shallowater City Hall at 806-696-4300 for the current figures. These numbers are general information, not financial advice, so confirm your own situation with the city and your lender. Septic installation is part of the build cost on a Trails lot, and our guide to wells, septics and utilities on Shallowater acreage covers what that involves.

The city is also planning the systems that new homes will connect to. On May 8, 2025, the Texas Water Development Board approved $8.4 million in financing for Shallowater to plan and design a new water source and water and wastewater improvements. The scope covers two to three wells, collection piping and a transmission line to the city's water treatment plant, along with a review of whether to expand the existing wastewater plant or build a new mechanical plant. A Citizen Portal summary of the October 14, 2025 council meeting reports that the council unanimously approved certificates of obligation to fund the engineering.

The latest status comes from a Citizen Portal account of an update given at the end of August 2026. It says the engineering firm Parkhill reported the water treatment plant application was under TCEQ review, and that the wastewater project ranked 180th of 250 for Clean Water State Revolving Fund financing. The city was following up with TWDB on next steps. If you're building in Shallowater over the next few years, these are the projects whose costs and timing feed into the town's utility rates.

Choosing Between the Two

The choice comes down to three questions. Is a home of about 1,600 square feet on a lot of about a seventh of an acre, at roughly $184 a square foot as of this fall, the right fit? Is a 2,400-square-foot custom home on a half acre with room for a shop worth the jump into the $520s? Or does a 1980s house a few blocks east, about $45,000 cheaper at the same size, do the job? Each option is real on Shallowater's streets right now. You can compare them on our Shallowater homes for sale page, and our earlier look at in-town Shallowater living versus nearby acreage covers the next step out from town.

If you're weighing a Highland Heights spec home, a Highland Trails lot, or selling an older Shallowater house to build, Panhandle Realty Group can price that decision with you. Dane Hensley has hands-on experience in custom home building, so we look at the lot, the house size and the cost to finish together. If you already own in town, start with your instant home valuation so you know what your current house brings toward the build.

Work With Us

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact us today.

Follow Me on Instagram